R&R

R&R means remove and replace. On a labor line it names one operation, taking a component off the vehicle and installing a new one, and the hours beside it come from a published time for that exact year, make and engine.

What does R&R stand for on an estimate?

Remove and replace. Counters write it R/R, guides print it R & R, and the operation behind all three spellings is the same: the old part comes off, a new part goes on, and the labor covers the access work in between. Book time supplies the hours when the shop has no template for the job. When the shop does have one, its canned job carries the hours and the wording instead, priced the way that shop has always priced it.

What does an R&R time leave out?

More than most people assume. Every published operation carries a footnote naming what it includes and what it excludes, and the exclusions are where an estimate goes short. Diagnosis is out, and it belongs on a line of its own, which the Federal Trade Commission tells customers to expect when it notes that "many repair shops charge for diagnostic time". So is machining, cleaning, flushing, programming a calibration into a module and the fluid that comes back out on the floor.

Seized hardware is out too. A published time assumes fasteners come loose, which is a reasonable assumption on a four-year-old truck and an optimistic one on a road-salt chassis with 240,000 miles. The shop that quotes an R&R and then spends ninety minutes extracting two broken studs is eating that time unless somebody called the customer first.

In some states that call is a legal step in the job. California's repair act says "No charge shall be made for work done or parts supplied in excess of the estimated price ... without the oral or written consent of the customer", and it wants that consent before the extra work happens. When the approval comes over the phone, the statute asks the shop to note on the work order the date, the time and the name of whoever authorized it, together with the additional parts and labor and the total. Write it down while the technician is still standing there with the torch, because reconstructing that conversation at pickup is a losing hand.

Is R&R the same as R&I?

No. R&I is remove and reinstall, which is what happens when a component has to come off to reach the actual repair and then goes back on the vehicle. Pulling a transmission to get at a rear main seal is R&I on the transmission. The seal itself is the replacement.

The distinction earns its keep in two places. Body shops write R&I constantly, because trim and lamps come off for refinish work and go back on. Drivetrain work uses it whenever a part is in the way, and an estimate that shows R&R on a component nobody replaced is a line a customer can win an argument over.

What happens when two R&R lines overlap?

The teardown gets billed twice. Two jobs on the same engine routinely share the same access work, and adding both published times together charges the customer for pulling the same intake off twice. Labor guides publish combination times for common pairs, and the second job gets its added time only.

Nobody does this on purpose. It happens when two jobs are priced on different afternoons by different people, or when a canned job written for a standalone repair gets dropped onto a ticket that already has the engine apart. Catching it means reading the whole estimate as one job list, which is why the audit for overlapping labor is worth building into the repair order review instead of trusting somebody to notice at 4 p.m.

Where does R&R get expensive on a diesel?

Access. On a Super Duty with the 6.7 Power Stroke, a fair amount of the engine lives under the cab, and the operations that need the cab lifted carry times that look wrong until you have seen the job. The same applies to a Duramax with the truck's front clip pulled forward. The hours are not padding, they are the removal work in front of the actual repair.

Two things follow from that. The teardown has to be quoted as its own decision, because a customer authorizing three hours of disassembly deserves to know that is what they are buying. And every single-use fastener the procedure calls out has to be on the parts list before the truck comes apart, since a cab-off job stopped by a missing $9 bolt is a bay tied up overnight.

The pricing side follows the same rule. An R&R line is worth what the guide says only when the guide was asked about the right engine, and the difference between two engine options in one body can be hours of billable work. The truck settles the question before the guide does. 49 CFR 565.15 requires positions four through eight of a truck's VIN to make its attributes decipherable, listed as "Make, model or line, series, chassis, cab type, engine type, brake system, gross vehicle weight rating." Decode it, then look up the operation.

Back to the glossary, or read how an estimate gets priced.